Here's the
big picture:
There will
be four big sessions and two much shorter evening sessions.
The big sessions, 3.5 hours each, will have a 45-minute break
in the middle. (So, for example, the 2-to-5:30 session will
run from 2:00 to 3:30 and from 4:15 to 5:30.)
The general
BigHook idea is to engage each other in discussion. I do not
know where discussion will take us this time. I've tried to
do the BigHook2001 agenda with enough generality that we can
discover new directions together but with enough specificity
that we're not looking for the same old keys under the same
old streetlight.
We will
all need to cooperate! It is not easy to do a discussion when
50 smart, active, accomplished, verbal people are dealing with
topics about which they know a lot and have strong opinions.
With 50 people in the room, a discussion will only work in an
atmosphere of respectful listening. Furthermore, it will only
work if, when we do speak, we are conscious of our tone of voice,
the airtime we're using, and the contribution we're making to
each other.
This year,
we're going to try something new -- we'll open each discussion
with an informal panel. I've tentatively assigned panelists
-- see below. The role of these panelists will be more discussion-starter
than knowledge-transferor. It'd be good if each panelist prepares
3 to 5 minutes giving their perspective on the session's topic
-- especially on what they view to be the critical questions.
(The exception to the 3-5 minute rule is that I'd like David
Reed and Clay Shirky to prepare to speak longer, 20 minutes
each, on The Architecture of Innovation.)
If you're
listed as a panelist and don't want to be, write me. If you're
not listed, and want to be a panelist, write to me too. If you
think you're on the wrong panel, ditto.
Also, this
year I'm going to try to facilitate some of the sessions myself.
I may invite couple of other BigHookers with facilitation experience
to guest-facilitate a session or two too. If you're qualified
and interested, please contact me.
Finally,
if you're not a panelist, and you're too shy to just jump into
the conversation, everybody will have a coupon good for three
minutes of floor time, which they can "play" by handing it to
the facilitator at any time.
Here's the
agenda:
Wednesday
- 9/5 -- Noon to 2:00 PM - Check in, lunch, swimming, meet
fellow participants.
Wednesday
- 9/5 -- 2:00 to 5:30 PM - Session 1: What boundaries? What
network?
Bushnell,
Cochrane, Kojima, Laws, Maffei, Wang -- We'll go around the
room and do introductions. I'll have a few words about what
I think the boundaries of the network are and why they are so
important. Then we'll kick off the discussion with a few words
from Nolan Bushnell, Dave Hofstatter and Andy Maffei about what
they're doing at their own network boundaries. After the break,
I'd like to get the international perspective of Peter Cochrane,
Malcolm Laws, Kojima-san and Gigi Wang about what' the boundaries
are in Europe and Asia, and on what Europeans and Asians think
is going on in the US of A.
Wednesday
- 9/5 -- 5:30 to 8:30 PM - New England Clambake, music by
Joe Weed and friends, fishing.
Wednesday
- 9/5 -- 8:30 to 9:30 PM - Session 2: Holy Halibut! What
happened to the Communications Revolution?
Googin,
Kamman, Stansberry, Weinberger -- One year ago, everybody except
Roxane Googin thought that the party would last all night. Now
Bob Berger says we're in the Dark Ages of Telecom. Matt Oristano
says, "The non-digerati think the net's a failure, Wall Street
says the techies overbuilt it and nobody came, the [geeks say]
the RBOCs ruined it, and the media say it was an investment
scam-bubble." What a difference a year makes. What happened?
Where are we now? Googin, Kamman and Stansberry will give investor
perspectives, then (I hope) Weinberger will tell us what he
thinks the Communications Revolution *really* is.
Thursday
- 9/6 -- 7:00 to 8:30 AM - Breakfast
Thursday
- 9/6 -- 8:30 AM to Noon - Session 3: Architectures of innovation
-- and their backlash.
Lessig,
Lucky, Reed, Shirky -- David Reed and Clay Shirky are two of
the clearest thinkers on the planet about how architecture is
destiny. There are architectures that foster innovation and
architectures that squelch it. Unfortunately, the architectures
that foster innovation seem to be the very ones that blow up
incumbent business models. After the break, Bob Lucky and Larry
Lessig will kick off a discussion of incumbent reactionism.
Thursday
- 9/6 -- Noon to 2:00 PM - Lunch, swimming.
Thursday
- 9/6 -- 2:00 to 5:30 PM - Session 4: Infrastructure of the
membrane.
Freeburg,
Hendricks, Norman, O'Dell, Oristano, Thatcher -- The access
architecture, like a cell membrane, has an active infrastructure
that intermediates between the inside and the rest of the world.
First, Norman, O'Dell and Thatcher will kick off a discussion
of the technology of wired access, then after the break, Freeburg,
Hendricks, and Oristano will set up the infrastructure of the
wireless infrastructure discussion.
Thursday
- 9/6 -- 5:30 to 8:30 PM - Dinner, music by Joe Weed and
friends, fishing.
Thursday
- 9/6 -- 8:30 to 9:30 PM - Session 5: The "free" market,
the Sweden/Canada model, or a third way?
Bradner,
Comstedt, Ekelund, St. Arnaud, Stansberry -- The current market
for network access , dominated by ILEC dinosaurs, isn't a "free
market" -- not by a long shot. I want to believe that Sweden
and Canada have the answer, but I've been around conservative
theorists like George Gilder and Porter Stansberry too long
to trust that they do. (For one thing, government mistakes,
like telco mistakes, tend to last and last and last.) I'm hoping
that we can rub Stansberry's criticism and Bradner's pragmatism
against the perspectives of St. Arnaud, Comstedt and Ekelund
to come up with better questions, or at least a good discussion.
Friday
- 9/7 -- 7:00 to 8:30 AM - Breakfast
Friday
- 9/7 -- 8:30 AM to Noon - Session 6: Where are the opportunities
under all these questions?
I'm not
going to nominate any panelists or attempt a description here.
I don't know where we'll be by Friday morning. I expect to be
surprised. My hope is that we will be able to gain a longer
perspective and identify new opportunities that will make the
network a better place to live and work, not only for us, but
for our childrens children, and for the 3 Billion people on
the planet who have not yet logged on.
Friday
- 9/7 -- Noon to 2:00 PM - Lunch, music by Joe Weed and friends.
Friday
- 9/7 -- 2:00 PM - Adjourn.